Raccoons
Task
On Saturday I picked the remaining carrots from my garden. I had 42 carrots in a paper bag on my porch. Well, it did not take long for a family of raccoons to discover my carrots!! When the 1st raccoon finished eating, there were 37 carrots left in the bag. When the 2nd raccoon finished nibbling, there were only 32 carrots left in the bag. The 3rd raccoon ate until there were exactly 27 carrots left in the bag. If the raccoons kept eating in this way, how many carrots did I find in the bag after the 7th raccoon had eaten? How can you be sure?
Show me your work and explain how you figured this out using as much math language as possible.
Alternate Versions of Task
| More Accessible Version:
I had 22 carrots in a paper bag on my porch. Well, it did not take long for a family of raccoons to discover my carrots! When the 1st raccoon finished eating, there were 20 carrots left in the bag. When the 2nd raccoon finished nibbling, there were only 18 carrots left in the bag. The 3rd raccoon ate until there were exactly 16 carrots left in the bag. If the raccoons kept eating in this way, how many carrots did I find in the bag after the 7th raccoon had eaten? How can you be sure?
Show me your work and explain how you figured this out using as much math language as possible.
More Challenging Version:
I had 44 carrots in a paper bag on my porch. Well, it did not take long for a family of raccoons to discover my carrots! When the 1st raccoon finished eating, there were 1/4 less carrots in the bag. When the 2nd raccoon finished nibbling, there were 5 fewer carrots in the bag. The 3rd raccoon ate 1/4 of what was left in the bag. The 4th raccoon ate 5 carrots. If the raccoons kept eating in this way, how many carrots did I find in the bag after the 6th raccoon had eaten? How can you be sure?
Show me your work and explain how you figured this out using as much math language as possible.
|
Context
This problem was relevant to the students' lives. All the children in our school had been harvesting all the vegetables from our school gardens in order to prepare for a community dinner that we sponsored. This dinner was part of a school-wide Common Roots interdisciplinary unit. The food for the dinner came from our school gardens, (some was supplemented by family gardens). We ran into lots of problems with raccoons eating our crops. This task was done in the middle of October with third and fourth graders.
What This Task Accomplishes
This task enabled students to recognize and extend a pattern and represent and describe mathematical relationships. This problem, while straightforward, allowed children to construct and organize their data.
What the Student Will Do
Many students will draw the number of carrots and cross them off by fives. Beware that with the numbers used in this problem, the answer may be correct with incorrect subtraction, (ex. 42 - 37 = 5 ... 7 ones subtract 2 ones equals 5). Many students will use tables and graphs.
Time Required for Task
1-2 hours
The time needed to solve this task varies; it takes most kids one or two 45-minute periods.
Interdisciplinary Links
As stated, this task was a part of a school-wide theme called Common Roots. This unit is part of our school's science and social studies curriculum. The culminating fall activity was preparing a harvest feast for the community. All the classes worked together to keep animals from eating our crops and to harvest what we had planted the previous spring. The children planned the menu for the dinner and prepared/cooked all the food.
Teaching Tips
Encourage children to use tables and/or graphs. Some children may want to use manipulatives. A discussion on organizing data should take place before this problem is given to students.
Suggested Materials- Graph paper
- Manipulatives to represent carrots and/or raccoons
- Markers and straight edges
Possible Solutions
At the Practitioner and Expert levels, students may arrive at the answer of seven carrots by using tables and graphs or computation.
| More Accessible Version Solution:
| Raccoons |
Carrots in Bag |
| 0 |
22 |
| 1 |
20 |
| 2 |
18 |
| 3 |
16 |
| 4 |
14 |
| 5 |
12 |
| 6 |
10 |
| 7 |
8 |
More Challenging Version Solution:
44 - 11 (raccoon #1) = 33 - 5 (raccoon #2) = 28 - 7 (raccoon #3) = 21-5 (raccoon #4) = 16 - 4 (raccoon #5) = 12 - 5 (raccoon #6) = 7 carrots
|
Task Specific Assessment Notes
Novice:
The Novice will not have an appropriate solution because the problem was not understood or a successful strategy was not employed. The Novice that is shown in this problem actually arrives at the correct solution, but it is clear from reading the student's explanation that appropriate procedures were not followed and that a solution was arrived at by accident. There is no math representation, although it is referred to.
Apprentice:
The student uses an appropriate strategy and graph leading toward a solution, but arrives at an incorrect solution by only subtracting for six raccoons instead of seven. The student did not finish the process. The graph shows that the student meant to use seven raccoons.
Practitioner:
The Practitioner has a broad understanding of the problem and major concepts and uses a strategy that leads to a solution. The use of the table allows the student to keep track of the number of raccoons. The student uses effective mathematical procedures. The explanation is clear and there is good use of mathematical representation.
|
Expert:
The student has a deep understanding of the problem and identifies the appropriate mathematical concepts. In addition to using a diagram to understand the problem and show reasoning, the student multiplies seven raccoons by five carrots and subtracts from 42 to arrive at seven carrots. There are multiple solutions. Mathematical representations are used appropriately and effectively. There is a very clear and effective explanation.
|
